We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
The best sauce for shrimp depends on how you plan to serve it. A chilled shrimp cocktail calls for a thick, tomato-based dip with horseradish, while shrimp scampi needs a warm, garlicky sauce designed for the skillet.
Consider the sauce’s flavor intensity before buying. Some options bring classic OLD BAY seasoning, others lean heavily into horseradish heat, and specialty products such as shrimp sauce or shrimp paste may suit different cooking styles.
Serving format matters, too. Ready-to-eat cocktail sauces are convenient for dipping, while McCormick’s scampi sauce is built around a quick pasta meal. The selections below cover straightforward dipping, bold spice and cooked seafood dishes.
| Product | Title | Key Features | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
#1Best Overall OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce Brand: OLD BAY
|
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
#2Best Specialty Pick Lee Kum Kee Shrimp Sauce Brand: Lee Kum Kee
|
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
#3Best for Pasta McCormick Scampi Sauce Brand: McCormick
|
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
#4Best for Heat St. Elmo Cocktail Sauce Brand: St Elmo Steak House
|
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
#5Best for Thai Thai Shrimp Shrimp Paste Brand: Thai Shrimp
|
|
Check Latest Price |
What to Look for in Best Sauce For Shrimp
- Choose a tomato-and-horseradish cocktail sauce for chilled shrimp, oysters or other seafood dipping.
- Look for a sauce with a clearly stated heat level if you prefer either gentle seasoning or a strong horseradish kick.
- Pick a cooking sauce such as scampi when you want to build a warm shrimp-and-pasta meal.
- Check the package size and price together, especially when comparing a single bottle with a two-pack.
- Pay attention to storage instructions, particularly for sauces that must be refrigerated.
#1 · Best Overall
OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce
OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce is a familiar choice for classic shrimp cocktail, combining tomato and horseradish with the brand’s recognizable blend of 18 spices and herbs. Celery salt and paprika add to its seasoned profile, while the thick texture makes it easy to scoop or dip. It suits shoppers who want a ready-to-eat seafood sauce with a recognizable OLD BAY character rather than a complicated cooking ingredient.
This bottle is especially practical for serving shrimp, oysters and crab cake sandwiches. There is no preparation described beyond pouring, dipping or spooning it directly onto food, so it fits casual appetizers and quick seafood plates. The stated flavor is bold with just the right amount of spice, making it a balanced everyday option for people who want noticeable seasoning without choosing the hottest sauce in the group.
Pros
- Ready to eat
- Thick dipping texture
- Classic tomato and horseradish base
- Works with shrimp, oysters and crab cakes
- Uses 18 spices and herbs
Cons
- Less suited to warm skillet meals
- Not the strongest heat option here
In everyday use, the thick consistency should stay neatly on shrimp instead of running immediately across the plate. Its intended uses are broad enough for a seafood platter, shrimp cocktail or sandwich, and the pour-and-dip format keeps serving simple. Compared with the scampi option, this is clearly designed for cold or direct serving rather than being heated with shrimp and pasta.
At $3.77 for 8 fluid ounces, it is the lowest-priced bottle among the listed cocktail sauces and costs less than the specialty two-pack. That makes it a sensible starting point for shoppers seeking a traditional seafood dip. Choose another product if you specifically want an extra-spicy horseradish experience or a sauce intended for a cooked entrée.
#2 · Best Specialty Pick
Lee Kum Kee Shrimp Sauce
Lee Kum Kee Shrimp Sauce is a more narrowly described option than the cocktail sauces in this roundup. The product information identifies it as shrimp sauce that is finely ground, giving shoppers a concise choice when they are specifically looking for this style of ingredient. It may appeal most to cooks who already have a particular recipe or regional preparation in mind.
Because the available product details do not describe a tomato base, heat level, serving method or complete pairing list, this is not the easiest bottle to recommend for a first-time shrimp cocktail shopper. Instead, it suits someone who recognizes finely ground shrimp sauce and wants a small 8-ounce product from Lee Kum Kee. The straightforward labeling keeps the choice focused, but leaves fewer usage cues than the other sauces.
Pros
- Finely ground shrimp sauce
- Recognized Lee Kum Kee brand
- Compact 8-ounce size
- Focused specialty ingredient
Cons
- Few usage details provided
- No stated heat level
- Not specifically described as cocktail sauce
In practical terms, this product is best approached as a specialty sauce rather than a universal dip. The listing does not say that it should be served chilled, heated or paired with pasta, so shoppers should match it to a recipe they already understand. That narrower role separates it from OLD BAY and St. Elmo, both of which explicitly describe seafood dipping use.
At $9.93 for 8 ounces, it costs more than the listed OLD BAY, McCormick and Thai Shrimp products, while offering less detail about preparation and pairings. Its value therefore depends on whether finely ground shrimp sauce is exactly what you need. If your priority is a clearly explained shrimp cocktail sauce, another selection provides more direct guidance.
#3 · Best for Pasta
McCormick Scampi Sauce
McCormick Scampi Seafood Sauce is made for a warm shrimp dinner rather than a chilled dipping platter. It delivers a rich, garlicky profile and includes herbs and spices such as red pepper, oregano and basil. The product is aimed at cooks who want to turn shrimp into a quick Italian-style meal, especially when serving the finished dish over linguine pasta.
The preparation is unusually clear: heat the sauce, add shrimp and stir until the shrimp are cooked. McCormick presents it as a 15-minute skillet meal, which makes it useful for a weeknight dinner when you want a defined cooking plan. It is also identified as Certified Kosher Dairy by the Chicago Rabbinical Council, a relevant detail for shoppers considering dietary requirements.
Pros
- Designed for shrimp scampi
- Rich garlic flavor
- Includes red pepper, oregano and basil
- 15-minute skillet meal
- Pairs with linguine
Cons
- Not intended as a cold dip
- Requires cooking
- Garlic-forward flavor may not suit every palate
This sauce fills a different role from the cocktail choices. Rather than spooning it onto prepared shrimp, you heat it in a skillet, add shrimp and stir until cooked, then serve the meal over linguine. That makes it the most directly useful option here for a complete warm entrée, while the simple instructions reduce the need to assemble a separate sauce.
At $5.54 for 7.5 ounces, it sits above OLD BAY’s listed price but below Lee Kum Kee and far below the St. Elmo two-pack. The price is easier to justify if you want a convenient shrimp-and-pasta format rather than a multipurpose seafood dip. Choose a cocktail sauce instead for appetizers or cold shrimp service.
#4 · Best for Heat
St. Elmo Cocktail Sauce
St. Elmo Cocktail Sauce is the boldest choice for shoppers who want an intensely spicy shrimp dip. It is made with fresh-ground horseradish root and balances that heat with tomato paste and hints of lemon. The brand describes a fiery, refreshing flavor with a long-lasting finish, making this a strong match for people who specifically enjoy a powerful horseradish punch.
The two-pack includes two 8-fluid-ounce bottles, so it can suit entertaining, gifting or keeping an extra bottle available. St. Elmo positions the sauce for shrimp and other seafood, with citrus notes intended to keep the flavor light despite its intensity. This is not the cautious, all-purpose pick; it is for diners who want cocktail sauce to make a dramatic impression.
Pros
- Very strong horseradish flavor
- Fresh-ground horseradish root
- Includes tomato and lemon notes
- Suitable for shrimp and other seafood
- Two 8-ounce bottles
Cons
- Most expensive option listed
- May be too hot for mild-sauce fans
- Requires refrigeration
For serving, this sauce is best suited to cold seafood platters and occasions where guests enjoy pronounced heat. The product specifically says it must be stored cold and should not remain at room temperature longer than 7–10 days, because it will begin to lose spiciness. It also lists an approximately six-month best-by date when stored, giving useful planning information for a two-bottle purchase.
At $24.99 for the two-pack, it costs substantially more than the single-bottle alternatives, but the comparison is not like-for-like because two 8-ounce bottles are included. Its value is strongest for horseradish enthusiasts, hosts and gift buyers. If you want moderate seasoning or a warm skillet sauce, OLD BAY or McCormick is a more natural fit.
#5 · Best for Thai
Thai Shrimp Shrimp Paste
Thai Shrimp Shrimp Paste is a compact specialty product identified as a product of Thailand. The listing provides a net weight of 90 grams, or 3.10 ounces, and names the product simply as shrimp paste. It is likely to interest shoppers who are looking for a specifically Thai ingredient rather than a ready-to-serve cocktail sauce, though the supplied details do not outline a recipe or serving method.
This option is therefore best for cooks who already know how they want to use shrimp paste. Unlike the cocktail sauces, it is not described as a dip for prepared shrimp, oysters or crab cakes. The product information also does not state a heat level, texture beyond the name “paste,” or recommended pairings, so it is a more specialized purchase than the clearly directed sauces in this selection.
Pros
- Product of Thailand
- Compact 90-gram size
- Specialty shrimp paste format
- Useful for cooks seeking a Thai ingredient
Cons
- No stated serving instructions
- Not described as a dipping sauce
- Smallest package listed
In real-world shopping, this product makes the most sense when a recipe specifically calls for Thai shrimp paste. Its smaller 3.10-ounce package may be convenient for limited use, but the listing does not explain whether it should be cooked, mixed or served directly. That lack of preparation guidance means it compares more closely with a pantry ingredient than with OLD BAY or St. Elmo cocktail sauce.
At $7.20, it costs more than the 8-ounce OLD BAY bottle and McCormick sauce, while providing a much smaller 90-gram quantity. The price may still be appropriate for a specialized ingredient, but it is not the value pick for someone simply wanting a shrimp dip. Choose it for its Thai shrimp paste identity, not for general-purpose cocktail serving.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best sauce for shrimp cocktail?
OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce is the clearest all-purpose choice because it is specifically described as a tomato-and-horseradish dipping sauce for shrimp cocktail. St. Elmo is another option if you want a much stronger horseradish flavor.
Which sauce is best for shrimp scampi?
McCormick Scampi Seafood Sauce is designed specifically for shrimp scampi. It is heated with shrimp and intended to be served over linguine as a 15-minute skillet meal.
Which shrimp sauce is the spiciest?
St. Elmo Cocktail Sauce is the strongest heat-focused option in this selection. Its fresh-ground horseradish, fiery flavor and long-lasting finish are aimed at shoppers who enjoy an intense cocktail sauce.
Can cocktail sauce be used with seafood besides shrimp?
Yes. OLD BAY lists oysters and crab cake sandwiches among its pairings, while St. Elmo describes its sauce as suitable for shrimp and other seafood. The products are therefore useful beyond a single shrimp dish.
Which product should I buy for a Thai recipe?
Thai Shrimp Shrimp Paste is the most directly relevant choice because it is identified as a product of Thailand and specifically labeled shrimp paste. The listing does not provide preparation instructions, so it is best for cooks who already have a recipe in mind.
Final Thoughts
For most shoppers seeking the best sauce for shrimp, OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce is the safest starting point: it is ready to eat, thick, clearly intended for dipping and priced lower than the other cocktail options listed. McCormick Scampi Seafood Sauce is the better answer when your goal is a warm shrimp-and-linguine dinner rather than an appetizer.
Choose St. Elmo for maximum horseradish heat and a two-bottle supply, Lee Kum Kee for a finely ground specialty shrimp sauce, or Thai Shrimp Shrimp Paste when a Thai ingredient is specifically required. Matching the product to the dish will matter more than choosing the most expensive bottle.
Mim Creation
Writer at Helmet Today, covering helmet reviews, fit and riding safety.
